Ethical Awareness (Full Disclosure) for Financial Expert Witnesses
Existing ethical standards have several implications for financial expert witnesses. It is in the best interest of financial expert witnesses to remain objective, independent, and accurate for legal, regulatory, and professional reasons. It is often the case that financial experts are CPFAs, and their AIPCA certifications require certain ethical conduct. Even though a financial expert witness may not be credentialed, all should comply by existing ethical standards. Accordingly, financial expert witnesses must abide by existing ethical standards by producing consistent results, maintaining independence, disclosing of all payments from respective parties, making unbiased analyses, disclosing all uncertainties, and reporting with accurate standards. Consistent analyses should yield consistent results according to ethical standards.
The legal parties do not dictate the conclusions of financial expert analyses. If that were the case, the opposing parties could produce starkly different results, creating confusion and uncertainty for the jury in question. To maintain ethical objectivity and independence, financial expert witnesses cannot allow payments to affect results.
Independent financial expert witnesses always disclose all payment agreements between themselves and the parties. Independent financial expert witnesses will never sacrifice ethical integrity to maintain working with regular clients. Lastly, financial expert witnesses under all circumstances must disclose any uncertainties in their valuation procedures. Not disclosing such uncertainties undermines the independence, reliability, and credibility of a financial expert witness. Each of considerations mentioned above preserves the objectivity, professionalism, and credibility of a financial expert witness, ultimately establishing and maintaining their ethical integrity and respect from the regulatory authorities and professional community. Independence requires that the expert not have economic, personal, or employment interests that impair the objectivity or independence of the testimony. For instance, an expert who is hired as a consultant by a party and is paid significant fees or commissions could be viewed as suspect. Codes of professional conduct prescribe that any such affiliations must be disclosed and, where feasible, avoided to safeguard independence. .
Full Disclosure
Full disclosure requires that the expert reveal all facts or circumstances that might reasonably bear on the court’s evaluation of the credibility or reliability of the expert’s testimony. Financial interests, prior relationships with the parties, published work, and other potential conflicts should be revealed. Disclosure is not just a procedural nicety, but a way for the court to weigh the proper evidentiary value of the expert’s opinion.
Consistent with Accepted Professional Standards
Financial expert witnesses are typically expected to frame their analysis within accepted principles such as Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), or the Uniform Standards of Professional Judgment (USPJ). The use of such professional standards has two ethical benefits. First, it lends comparability and verifiability to the testimony. If the testimony is prepared in accordance with GAAP, for example, the reader can expect to find a certain set of defined assumptions, inclusions and disclosures. Second, it avoids the shifting of standards in a way designed to reach a particular conclusion. For example, using a more favorable convention with regard to depreciation without recognizing that same convention as it affects other account statements would be a violation of reliability as well as objectivity.
The relevant action to fulfill the standard is to record the convention used, record the fact that there was a departure from the norm, and to explain in a simple way to a fact finder the relative significance of the departure.
Pressure and the role of Bias Litigation is a pressure cooker, and analysts need to be keenly aware of that when they accept employment in an action. Focus on that pressure and how you can avoid it impairing your decision making can be effective tools for the expert witness. Some additional ways that can help keep an expert honest include: 1) refusing to take the case in the first place. When the same lawyer approaches a witness time and again on the same issues, the risk of bias is too significant to allow the case to be taken, and a good analyst should not accept employment in such a case. 2) make sure that terms of employment are transparent. There should be a complete understanding at the outset about the scope of work, associated fees and costs and the basis on which the engagement might be terminated. 3) consider having a peer review of the work prepared during the course of the engagement.
While not always an option, when an engagement moves toward conclusion, consideration should be given on volition of the expert to having an independent verification of the materials. Ultimately, when an expert realizes that a position offered by another favor is less reliable or not entirely achievable by the test to be applied, the response should be to disclose the data in support of the alternative opinion and the basis on which the expert finds that data unsupported, and to decline prolffering a supported opinion with regard to that particular conclusion.
Disclosure has enhanced results Completing disclosure as thoroughly, simply and directly as possible makes it more useful. The expert should disclose. These disclosures are typically in the form of a letter, and are included in an expert report. The letter should state or disclose: The expert’s fees¢ any other remuneration, past or future Relationship with the parties¢. salary, bonus, retainer, current client, past client, whitepapers published, board or affiliate positions Education, affiliations, editorial boards, and other relevant publications The expert should also disclose their basis for data points: data sources used, sample selection methodology, assumptions made in modeling, inputs provided by the attorneys and assumptions or scenario analysis completed as part of the work performed. This helps the court to better understand the expert’s conclusions.
Caveat the Conclusions In many matters, there will not be an exact number, nor a precise solution or interpretation of the numbers. An expert has the duty to explain this is the case and provide an appropriate range of values or opinions. He or she may state the chosen value and why, but also state what a second approach has resulted in and then explain why the chosen approach is better than a third approach. These points should not be omitted, and like the use of uncertainty (confidence limits for example), indicate that the expert is not attempting to hide something from the court. Default on a Duty When an expert fails to uphold their duties, there are several remedies and disciplinary actions. These follow the rules of the court, and can include: Monetary sanctions, exclusion of the testimony, and expert’s disciplinary bodies. Furthermore, the consequences of unethical testimony can result in unjust outcomes, including potential miscarriages of justice and diminished trust in legal institutions. All of this makes ethics a direct, non‑negotiable factor in a finance expert’s standards of care.
Conclusion
Financial experts who serve as witnesses bear significant responsibility in upholding the objectivity, independence, and accuracy of the information presented in court. Adhering to principles of transparent disclosure and rigorous, unbiased analysis ensures that expert opinions carry the weight of impartial reasoning and factual support. Recognizing and aligning practice with the ethical standards outlined by professional organizations, maintaining professional independence, revealing compensation, conducting thorough vetting of information, and candidly discussing areas of opinion and uncertainty all contribute to ethical, effective participation as a court finance expert.
